![]() |
|
“Moral Economies”
Luke 11:5-8
A sermon preached by the
Rev. Douglas M. Donley
February 5, 2006
On my daily appointment with the
treadmill in Tuesday’s predawn, I was flooded with two images that came across
the television screen. The first was the
scene of an injured and bull who leaped in to the stands at a bullfight in
The
other image was the first news of the death of Coretta Scott King, a woman who
had dealt with her fair share of raging bulls in her life and through it all
kept her faithfulness and her commitment to nonviolence.
Through
all of this, the image of the raging bull has danced around in my imagination.
Then
on Friday, I got the call from UBC’s former pastor Nadean Bishop who told me
that her daughter had just taken her own life.
We
see raging bulls all around us. The question
we need to ask is how do we tame the raging bull.
We
need to first ask what makes the bulls rage.
Then
we need to find ways to stop making the bulls rage.
And
if we can’t stop them from raging, then we need to find a way to manage their
rage.
And
if we can’t find a way to manage their rage, then we’re in big trouble.
So
let’s look at the source of the bull’s rage.
In a literal sense, the bull was cornered. He was injured and was going to take out his
aggression on anyone nearby. When you
get into that kind of mindset, when you are a cornered and injured bull, it
makes no sense to reason with you about why you’re upset. You are fighting for your life and rage is
the final desperate thing you can do. A
raging bull, when threatened will act out of desperation. It no longer cares who is in his way. It gets attention.
When
I think of the raging bulls in today’s world I think of terrorism. I think of racism, I think of homoprejudice
(which is different from homophobia) and its self-righteous exclusion. And I even think about the proliferation of
depression. I am not calling people
raging bulls, although some may appear that way, but I think that some people
caught in racism, homoprejudice and severe depression might have the raging
bull mentality.
The
raging bull mentality is a defensive mentality that acts out of that sense of
being cornered. It doesn’t know where to
turn. It leaves people injured and even
dead in its wake. It is not
rational. As such it can’t be quickly
reasoned with. It cares not who is
injured by its fury. It is a last
desperate act of an injured party.
In
the 40th movement of Handel’s Messiah, the Bass singer asks the
question quoting Psalm 2, “Why do the nations so furiously rage together? Why do the people imagine a vain thing? The kings of the earth rise up and the rulers
take counsel together.”
If
we are not careful, a people who have been victimized, may well become a raging
bull. I don’t pretend to know about the
desperation that has unleashed the raging bull of Al Qaida. I certainly don’t
want to make any excuses for their despicable actions. But I
wonder if a part of it may have to do with the fact that our world is not being
moral enough in the way it runs its economy.
I know that the
It
doesn’t help that we continue to pollute our world.
It
doesn’t help that we collude with the IMF and the World Bank to keep the third
world in perpetual debt.
It
doesn’t help that we unleash a doctrine of preemptive strike against suspected
terrorist harboring countries.
It
doesn’t help when we spy on our own people or use apocalyptic religion to
justify all of our world dominance.
It
should not surprise us that we might unleash raging bulls.
The
chorus of people, the masses, respond to the Bass’s question in the next
movement of Handel’s Messiah with these words: “Let us break their bonds
asunder and cast away their yokes from us.”
We unleash raging bulls all the time.
The
irony of racism and homoprejudice is that the raging bull ends up being the
ones presently in power instead of those victimized. They stir up their flocks with rhetoric that
puts them in the victims stead. They are
taking away the American way of life.
They are taking away our schools.
They are stomping on the scared institution of marriage. They want your children next. And if we get stirred up enough the raging
bulls will come out and God help us if we are in their way.
Coretta
Scott King saw first hand how the raging bull cut down her husband Martin
Luther King and so many more people. She
saw the way that people who had lost their rationality could do unspeakable
things. And she struggled her whole life
to create a world where the raging bulls would not have a foothold.
She sought ways to make sure
the bulls never got to the raging point.
That was her genius. It was her
Christian duty. It was her vision that
merits attention today.
She
and Martin embraced a concept of a vision of a beloved community. One where not only did people not judge one
another on the basis of their skin color, but that dealt with each other on an
equal basis regardless of their personal abilities or their economic
standing. To treat people with less
than full dignity not only dehumanizes the other person and potentially
unleashes the raging bull. It also
dehumanizes us. If we seek to simply win
over an enemy and not seek reconciliation with a brother or sister, then we
have ultimately gained nothing.
We
have become what we despise in another—judgmental, unwilling to hear another
side, even violent.
Coretta
Scott King worked on the Poor People’s Campaign in
I
heard Coretta Scott King Speak at my alma mater twenty something years
ago. She said that people had misnamed
and therefore misinterpreted the movement of Martin Luther King as passive
resistance. She said that there is
nothing passive about nonviolence. She
called on us to be engaged not in passive resistance, but active nonviolence.
Active
nonviolence continues to ask the hard questions.
It
continues to educate people.
It
continues to try to make relationships even with those with whom you disagree.
It
continues to do direct action when negotiation fails.
And
it continues to resist the temptation to violence which might just unleash a
raging bull or two.
In
today’s parable, Jesus tells of a person who comes to a friend’s door in the
middle of the night so he can give bread to a friend who has come to
visit. In the ancient culture, it was
essential that they offer hospitality to a stranger. It would be unthinkable to deny this person’s
request. Such is the moral economy of
the peasant. Even when they are without
many goods, they will give you what they have because you are a guest and you
honor them by your presence. We saw this
in
Initially,
the friend does not open the door. This
was a shameful thing to do, not opening the door and refusing the opportunity
of hospitality. But the neighbor had
forgotten the community obligation. He
was tired and maybe was saving his bread for his own consumption. But the neighbor kept on knocking. His persistence reminded him that he needed
to do the right thing. His persistence
reminded him and the whole town that we needed to have an economy based upon
morality and that part of that morality meant that no one would go hungry and
that a stranger was as important as a member of your own family.
The
book or Revelation calls those who are in the churches in their apocalyptic
time to engage in persistent resistance to the forces of evil which were
personified in the emperor and his minions.
We
need some persistent non-violent resistance these days. We need resistance against the forces of
judgment and demonizing and warfare.
It
is the resistance that offers hospitality in the face of injustice. It is the resistance that stays persistent
not only because we demand justice for ourselves, but because of that denial of
justice does to our adversaries. King
sought to do good so all could enjoy the beloved community.
The
only way to effectively tame a raging bull is to make sure the bull has nothing
to rage about.
The
most effective form of resistance is non-violent and life-giving instead of
life-taking. It means imagining how we
can transform our enemies into friends.
That’s what we need to be looking at long-term if we are to tame the
raging bulls of the world. We need to
not give them something to rage about.
As I
look at the raging bulls that are inside so many of us in the form of
depression and despair, I can’t help but think that we need to find ways that
we can befriend those who need it. It
may not be a way to ultimately tame the raging bull of depression, but might be
the place where we can offer a word of hope to a person in need.
I
heard the news of Nadean’s daughter Susan’s suicide and I thought about those
close to me who have contemplated suicide.
To commit suicide is to succumb to the raging bull. It leaves all of those around it bruised and
broken. I wondered what it might have
been like to be the friend at
There
is no easy answer to this. We can’t
ultimately stop someone from committing suicide. But we can offer sincere friendship to those
who need it. Sometimes we can be like
the friend knocking on the door at
That
we are willing to grant them hospitality and even hold their hands so that the
raging bulls will not have the final say, but friendship and hospitality will.
Radical
befriending is subversive, liberating, even God-inspired work. It is ultimately what Jesus called us to
do. It is what Jesus called us to be. The moral economy is an extension of our
capacity to offer friendship to those who need it most.
May
we so do it.